Before you buy AI interview software, ask the vendor five sets of questions: who makes the hiring decision, how the scoring is tested for bias, what the candidate is told, where interview data is stored and for how long, and what one interview costs at your volume. A vendor that cannot answer clearly is a compliance risk you inherit.
That is the short answer. Below are the twelve questions we would ask, why each one matters in 2026, and what a good answer sounds like.
Why this matters now
AI interviews have moved from pilots to the default first round. In Greenhouse's 2026 candidate survey, 63% of job seekers said they had faced an AI interview. Vendors are racing to add voice agents: HireVue bought the technology behind Hireguide in March 2026 to build a voice-based AI interviewer, and on 15 October 2026 Greenhouse launched a voice AI first interview inside its ATS, citing its research that 86% of US recruiters say at least half of applications are AI-written.
Hiring teams still want people to decide. In a Willo survey reported by People Matters, 78.7% of hiring teams said final hiring decisions should stay in human hands. The law points the same way, and as the employer you carry the duty even when the tool is bought. More choice makes the buying questions matter more.
Decisions and oversight
1. Does the tool ever reject a candidate on its own? A good answer: no, it scores and summarises, and a recruiter moves every candidate forward or out. Our post on whether AI should reject candidates automatically explains why this matters.
2. Can a recruiter see why a candidate got a score? Ask to see a real scorecard: the questions, the answers, the rubric and the evidence for each rating. A single number with no reasons is hard to defend to a candidate or a regulator.
3. Can we set and edit the questions and the rubric? Every candidate for a role should get the same questions, scored against the same criteria. That is what makes a structured interview fair, and you should own the criteria, not the vendor.
Bias and testing
4. Has the scoring been audited for bias, and can we see the results? New York City's Local Law 144 bars employers from using an automated employment decision tool unless it has had a bias audit within the past year and a summary is public. Even if you do not hire in New York, the question tells you whether the vendor measures outcomes by group at all.
5. What happens to candidates with accents, speech differences or poor connections? Ask how the tool handles a dropped call, background noise and non-native speakers, and whether a candidate can ask for a human interview instead.
6. Which law-specific duties does the product support? Under Article 26 of the EU AI Act, employers using high-risk AI must assign trained people to oversee it, keep its logs for at least six months and tell workers before use; for stand-alone high-risk systems these duties apply from 2 December 2027. Illinois requires notice when AI is used in hiring decisions, and Colorado's SB26-189 takes effect on 1 January 2027. Ask which of these the vendor's features cover, in writing.
Candidates and data
7. What exactly does the candidate see and hear? Ask for the invitation email, the disclosure that an AI is conducting the interview, and a test interview of your own. Our post on telling candidates about AI interviews covers what to say.
8. Where is interview data stored, who can access it and when is it deleted? For Indian candidates, the DPDP Rules, 2025 were notified on 14 November 2025 with an eighteen-month phased compliance period. You need a retention period you can state in your notice and a way to delete one candidate's data on request.
9. Is our data used to train the vendor's models? Get a yes or no in the contract, and check which third-party AI models process the audio and transcripts.
10. How does the tool check that the candidate is who they say they are? Remote fraud is a real problem; see our guide on spotting fake candidates.
Cost and fit
11. What does one interview cost, all in? Per-seat, per-interview and per-minute pricing look very different at 50 candidates a month and at 5,000. Ask for a worked example at your volume, and ask about minimums, setup fees and what happens when you go over a tier. Our cost per hire calculator helps you compare.
12. Does it fit the way we already hire? Check whether it works with your ATS or replaces it, which languages and channels (phone, video, chat) it supports, and how long setup takes. A tool recruiters bypass after a month saves nothing.
How GetHirePlus answers these
For comparison, here is how we answer the cost and decision questions. GetHirePlus AI phone interviews ask every shortlisted candidate the same questions and give the recruiter a scored summary; a person makes the decision. The Starter plan is $0/month with AI interview time at $0.14/min (₹12), and Growth is $100/month plus $0.09/min (₹8), with no minimums and no setup fee; prices exclude GST. If you bring your own LLM and API key, there is no per-minute interview fee. The full arithmetic per interview length is on our pricing page. Use the twelve questions on us too.
Sources
Greenhouse, 63% of job seekers have faced an AI interview (2026 candidate AI interview report)
EU AI Act Service Desk, Article 26: obligations of deployers of high-risk AI systems
Council of the EU, Digital Omnibus on AI final approval (29 June 2026)
Illinois Public Act 103-0804 (AI in employment decisions)